Sunday, July 25, 2021   

  Home     About     Guest Editorials     Advertise     Blog     Site Map     Links     Contact      Subscribe RSS      Subscribe Email  
Home » General

Brooklyn mosque row reflects wider tensions

11 May 2011 General 3 Comments Email This Post Email This Post

Some argue the row over the Sheepshead Bay mosque is the latest sign of US "Islamophobia"

By Laura Trevelyan BBC News, New York

Protesters who want to stop the construction of a mosque in Brooklyn’s Sheepshead Bay are bringing their case to court on Tuesday, the latest in a series of such disputes across America.

The nation founded on the principle of freedom of religious worship is seeing disputes from Tennessee to New York’s Staten Island, as Muslims wishing to build places of worship run into opposition – almost 10 years after the 9/11 attacks.

The most high profile case was the Islamic centre to be built close to Ground Zero in Manhattan – now it’s the turn of what critics call the Brooklyn “mega-mosque”.

Opponents of the Sheepshead Bay development – who include blogger Pamela Geller, an influential critic of Islam – say it will dramatically alter the quality of life in a quiet, residential neighbourhood.

Traffic, parking difficulties and the noise of the call to prayer will be disruptive, says the group suing to stop the construction, called Bay People.

“The neighbourhood residents are mostly of Italian/Russian/Jewish/Irish descent and will not benefit from having a mosque and a Muslim community centre,” the Bay People website states.

But others accuse the group of a thinly-veiled anti-Muslim agenda.

‘Extremist organisation’

“They are using traffic and noise as this smokescreen for their bigoted agenda against the Muslim community establishing a mosque in Sheepshead Bay,” says Debbie Almontaser of the Muslim Consultative Network, a group advising Sheepshead Bay Muslims.

Ill-feeling has been further stirred by the death of Osama Bin Laden.

While the Obama administration has taken pains to assert that Bin Laden was not a Muslim leader and that America’s war is “not against Islam”, a number of public expressions of anti-Muslim sentiment have since occurred around the US.

Almontaser says that since Bin Laden’s killing, the walls of the Sheepshead Bay property have been vandalised with graffiti that says “He is dead”.

Meanwhile, Geller, who writes the blog Atlas Shrugs, takes issue with the Muslim American Society, a group backing the mosque’s construction.

“It’s a proxy of the Muslim Brotherhood, an extremist organisation,” she says.

“They’re violating building codes, yet the city, and government officials are in the tank on these issues, it’s political correctness. They’re trying to establish a rabat, a beachhead, in a small residential neighbourhood.”

Bay People cites parking concerns as a major objection – yet Debbie Almontaser says the 200 families who will use the mosque live within walking distance of it, and won’t be driving.

The mosque’s developer has said the call to prayer will not be broadcast, out of sensitivity to the non-Muslims in the area.

The protesters are keeping a close eye on the construction, which has resulted in one “stop-work order” when city inspectors found a violation of building rules.

The question is whether a court case based on claims that the mosque and community centre violate zoning laws can succeed in a nation where there’s a constitutional right to freedom of religion.

Ms Almontaser says Muslim Americans will stand up for those rights against what she calls a national epidemic stemming from Islamophobia.

While local opponents of the Sheepshead Bay mosque state their opposition in terms of noise concerns, national critics of Islam see its construction as yet another encroachment by what they believe is a repressive ideology.

Original post: Brooklyn mosque row reflects wider tensions


  1. It is the first I have heard about the issue, but if building the church violates zoning laws how were they able to even begin the building process? Quite a bit of paperwork has to be done before any groundbreaking on any site so it seems to me if it is being built then complaints about zoning are quite a bit behind their times. I hope that this is updated so that a clearer picture is seen.

  2. Who cares about laws. There are no laws for MAS. Nobody even pay attention about violation. They do what they want to do they have support from all officials. No democracy at all.

Have your say!

Add your comment below, or trackback from your own site. You can also subscribe to these comments via RSS.

Be nice. Keep it clean. Stay on topic. No spam.

You can use these tags:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>