Friday, July 23, 2021   

  Home     About     Guest Editorials     Advertise     Blog     Site Map     Links     Contact      Subscribe RSS      Subscribe Email  
Home » General

OC Muslims Connect With Japanese-American Internment Struggle at Manzanar

2 May 2012 General 7 Comments Email This Post Email This Post
Manzanar memorial monument.

Manzanar memorial monument.

By Yasmin Nouh Mon., Apr. 30 2012 at 3:00 PM, OC Weekly

John Asanuma was 11 years old when President Franklin D. Roosevelt signed Executive Order 9066, paving the path for mass imprisonment of Japanese Americans after Pearl Harbor. The Los Angeles native, and his parents were sent to Manzanar in 1942–one of the largest camps housing more than 120,000 Japanese Americans during World War II. The desert weather at the camp, located near Death Valley, brought in scorching summers and chilling winters. When it snowed, John and his friends built makeshift snow slides. During the other seasons, they played softball with sticks and pine cones. Three years later, officials closed the camp, and John and his parents moved to Fresno.

“When I left camp, the first thing I did was kiss the street,” he said. “I felt my sense of freedom again.”

Asanuma revisited the camp on Saturday at the yearlyManzanar Pilgrimage, a day-long program dedicated to remembering that dark era in American history and the lessons that came out of it. The annual program draws approximately 1,000 participants; among them was a group of about 50 Muslim Americans, hosted by the Anaheim-based chapter of the Council on American Islamic Relations (CAIR).

“It’s important for Muslim Americans to understand how another group struggled,” said CAIR spokesperson Munira Syeda. “And what happens if people remain silent and don’t stand up for the rights our Constitution grants us.”

Munira said that members of the Japanese-American community, like Kathy Masaoaka, were among the first groups to reach out to Muslim Americans post-9/11 attacks. Masaoka fought for government reparations for the Japanese American community in the 1980s, and now she co-chairs Nikkei for Civil Rights and Redress. She said she understood the importance of reaching out to Muslims after 9/11.

“When I heard Muslim and Arab-Americans talking about how afraid they were after 9/11, that’s when I understood how our community felt for the first time,” she said. “I didn’t understand it before – feeling that fear just because of the way you looked.”

The relationship between both groups culminated in programs like Bridging Communities (a learning exchange between Japanese-American and Muslim-American students) and a yearly trip to Manzanar. Around 50 Muslim Americans attended the pilgrimage this year. Some of them said they barely learned about the internment camps in high school, and they wanted to find out more about the history.

Among them was Kashif Ghani, who leads weekend religious studies classes at a Mission Viejo mosque. While he said he can’t compare the Japanese-American experience to that of Muslims in America, he felt empowered by the trip.

“After 9/11, I didn’t want to get involved,” 25-year-old Kashif said. “I wanted to avoid confrontation. Coming here and seeing how Japanese-Americans have confronted the government inspired me to not feel ashamed. We didn’t do anything wrong, and we shouldn’t feel afraid to say anything against the government or bad policies.”

Kashif convinced most of his students from the mosque to attend this year’s program. During the day, they walked around the site, prayed in an interfaith memorial service for those who died at Manzanar, and participated in an evening breakout session where former incarcerees (or their children) shared their experiences as internees at Manzanar.

In one of the discussion groups, Don Hosokawa of Huntington Beach said his parents were interned at Manzanar, and two of his sisters were born there. At the camp, his father used to sneak out with friends at night to fish at streams nearby; a documentary called Manzanar Fishing Club was later made about the fishermen. As Hosokawa shared his parents’ story, other group members reflected on discrimination in general, including Omar Jarrad, a Muslim-American of Palestinian descent. The eighth grader at Las Flores Middle School in Rancho Santa Margarita, said that some of his fellow peers repeatedly taunt him at school by calling him names like “camel jockey” and “terrorist.”

“Hey, don’t feel bad,” Don said to Omar. “We went through this stuff, so just know that you’re not alone.”

Jarrad said he learned a lot about the struggles of Japanese Americans at the camp site; the experience empowered him. “It made me believe in myself,” he said. “And I’m not going to listen to those who make fun of me anymore. I don’t feel alone anymore.”

Other Muslim-Americans found meaning in the trip, as well. Hanan Seirafi, an economics major at UC Irvine, wanted to visit the site to learn more about the firsthand experiences of Japanese American internees.

“The fact that fear can do this to innocent people is shocking,” she said. “As Muslims today, we’re being analyzed through a scope of fear so it draws a connection. It’s hard not to make that connection.”Follow OC Weekly on Twitter @ocweekly or on Facebook


  1. I remember watching TV in the immediate aftermath of 9/11 and was struck by the images of Boston police perp-walking some bearded, turbaned men off to jail. My immediate reaction was, “Hey, those are Sikhs!” My next thought was, “Here we go again!”

    All of my extended family in California was rounded up in 1942 and shipped off to so-called “Internment” camps following the attack on Pearl Harbor. The nation was swept along on a tide of paranoia and race hysteria, and the handiest scapegoats were the Japanese living in the U.S. (2/3 of whom were native-born citizens). The aftermath of 9/11 seemed to be poisoned with the same feelings. So some friends and I made a point of attending the solidarity vigil at the Japanese American National Museum in Downtown L.A.

    In the time since, through my involvement with the Manzanar Committee, I have worked with CAIR in conjunction with the annual Pilgrimage described in the article above. On a more personal level, I have met and befriended many muslims (Americans of Arabic, Persian, Indonesian and Algerian descent) and come to relish Middle Eastern and North African food and music. My fellow Americans have added new flavors and tones to my life.

    I am also the writer-producer of the documentary film mentioned in the article above, “The Manzanar Fishing Club.” We tell the story of those who found freedom and sanity while being incarcerated by going fishing. Doing something “normal” took on new meaning and importance. We open May 4 at the Regency South Coast Village (next to South Coast Plaza). Come see us if you get the chance.

  2. Pilgrimage to Manzanar for me was one of the most spiritual retreats I have ever taken. It was my blessing to go in 2008 with friends from NCRR and CAIR. To this day I play the youtube, “Manzanar at Dusk” wrap up with Ameena and George, Ameena singing the names of Allah, George playing the flute, introduction by Hussam.

    “Generalizing about any community is wrong. What we have learned here we have to take back to our community”. This is what a retreat does for your soul, replenishes you, solidifies solidarity, fills you with strength. I hope to go again, and want to say, my experience from four years ago is still with me. Thank you CAIR, NCRR, JACL and the Manzanar Committee. You’ve created a winner with this one, a most special experience of solidarity of the human soul.

  3. We will never allow an illegal internment happen again to anyone. That will be an act of war.

  4. For me, the National Park system serves a great purpose. I’ve been to many of them, but I think this park has to be one of the most important – if not THE most important. Visiting any day of the year is an incredibly moving experience, so I just couldn’t imagine the range of emotions there on this particular day. Next year, I think I need to go.

  5. when fighting monsters one must be careful not to become the monsters which they fight.

  6. Muslims will establish their own internment camps.

    They will not abandon their dreams of theocratic domination and kicking the rest of us into despised secondary position. They will attempt to establish theocratic muslim territories within the US by harassing non muslims out of their chosen areas.

    By and by these areas will need fences and armed guards.

    They will stockpile weapons, read the Koran all day and thirst for the blood of the unbelievers. Similar to Waco/Koresh.

    There will be blood.

  7. Amen

Have your say!

Add your comment below, or trackback from your own site. You can also subscribe to these comments via RSS.

Be nice. Keep it clean. Stay on topic. No spam.

You can use these tags:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>